Breaking in engines with oil additives

by Alex

Expert answer:

Quick Answer

Using oil additives during engine break-in is not recommended as new engines need controlled friction for proper piston ring seating. Friction-reducing additives can interfere with this critical process, potentially causing long-term performance issues.

Expanded Answer (Simplified)

New engines require a specific break-in process where piston rings gradually wear against cylinder walls to create proper sealing. This process needs a certain amount of friction to work correctly, and oil additives that reduce friction can interfere with proper ring seating.

During break-in, typically the first 500-1,000 miles, engines need to develop proper surface finishes and clearances. Using friction modifiers or other performance additives can prevent this natural wearing process, leading to poor compression, increased oil consumption, and reduced engine life.

The best approach is to use a dedicated break-in oil or follow the manufacturer’s recommendations exactly. These oils are formulated with the right balance of protection and controlled friction to ensure proper component seating without causing damage.

Expanded Answer (Technical)

Engine break-in requires controlled tribological conditions to achieve optimal surface finishes, ring-to-bore conformity, and bearing clearances. Oil additives can disrupt these critical processes through inappropriate friction modification and surface chemistry alteration.

Ring Seating Requirements

Proper piston ring break-in requires specific friction coefficients and surface interaction parameters:

Initial friction coefficient: 0.08-0.12 for controlled wearing
Surface roughness reduction: From Ra 0.8-1.2μm to Ra 0.2-0.4μm
Ring face conformity: 85-95% contact area within 500 miles
Blow-by reduction: From 15-25 CFM to <5 CFM at rated conditions

Additive Interference Mechanisms

Friction modifiers and extreme pressure additives can interfere with break-in through several mechanisms. Boundary lubrication films from molybdenum disulfide or PTFE can prevent necessary metal-to-metal contact required for surface conditioning. Anti-wear additives like ZDDP can form protective films that inhibit controlled wearing processes.

Detergent-dispersant additives can also interfere by removing beneficial break-in debris that aids in surface polishing, while viscosity improvers may provide excessive film thickness that prevents proper ring-to-bore contact pressure.

Break-in Oil Specifications

Optimal break-in oils typically contain reduced additive packages with 10-15% total additives compared to 20-25% in fully formulated oils. Zinc levels are often reduced to 800-1000 ppm compared to 1200-1400 ppm in regular oils to allow controlled wearing.

Professional break-in protocols specify oil change intervals of 500-1000 miles initially, with oil analysis monitoring to verify proper ring seating through blow-by measurements, compression testing, and wear metal analysis to ensure optimal engine conditioning without excessive component wear.

Read the full article.

Share This Post:

Contact us

Find us on:

Newsletter