Quick answer
Engine oil additives can be good when resolving mild issues—like small leaks or sludge. They’re bad if used improperly or if your engine doesn’t need them. Proper matching is crucial for positive results.
Detailed answer
Many people swear by additives that hush valvetrain ticking or reduce oil seepage around old seals. Others end up with foaming, reduced oil pressure, or emission woes from the wrong additive. The difference is understanding your engine’s condition and the additive’s formula. For example, a high-zinc blend might be good for a classic car but harmful to a modern catalytic converter. A cleaning additive can help with mild sludge, but if your engine is pristine, it might not offer any benefit. “Good or bad” depends on thoughtful, informed usage, not a blanket yes or no.