Why is diesel cleaner than gasoline?

by Alex

Expert answer:

Quick answer

Some people consider diesel cleaner because it often produces less CO2 per mile than gasoline. However, diesel can create higher nitrogen oxide levels. Modern exhaust technologies and proper upkeep help reduce diesel’s particulates, making it cleaner in certain conditions.

Detailed answer

The claim that diesel is cleaner than gasoline usually hinges on carbon dioxide comparisons. Many diesel engines manage to produce less CO2 per mile, which can look like a big plus if you’re trying to keep down greenhouse gas output. Yet, diesel exhaust is not entirely squeaky clean, since it often contains more nitrogen oxides (NOx) and particulates that impact local air quality. This complex balance of fewer carbon emissions versus higher toxic particles can be confusing, so it’s best to break down how diesel achieves those lower CO2 levels and why it’s not the sole measure of cleanliness.

In a diesel engine, compression ignites the fuel rather than a spark plug. This process tends to be more efficient, squeezing more energy from each litre of fuel. Because of that efficiency, diesel engines generally sip fuel more slowly, which helps them churn out fewer grams of CO2 per mile. This trait is especially handy on longer journeys where the engine maintains optimal temperature and benefits from steady speeds, such as on major roads and motorways across the UK.

On the other hand, the higher combustion temperatures in many diesel engines can lead to elevated NOx emissions, known for aggravating respiratory issues and contributing to smog. Diesel vehicles can also produce minute soot particles that, if not caught by a properly functioning diesel particulate filter, float into the environment and reduce air quality in densely populated areas. This is why some city councils place strict rules or fees on older diesel cars, aiming to curb pollution hot spots near busy roads.

However, modern diesel powertrains are not stuck in the past. Engineers have introduced technologies like selective catalytic reduction (SCR), exhaust gas recirculation (EGR), and sophisticated filters. These systems capture or neutralise a fair portion of those problematic pollutants. If the vehicle is maintained well and driven enough to heat the filter—allowing it to burn off accumulated particles—diesel can remain quite clean in practice. The key is that these systems need consistent care, such as quality fuel, proper oil changes, and occasional longer drives to clear out the filter.

For the everyday UK driver, deciding if diesel is cleaner than gasoline might depend on driving routines. If you mostly travel long distances, diesel’s efficiency and reduced CO2 can be appealing. But if you’re often stuck in short city commutes, a gasoline car or low-emission alternative might produce fewer harmful local pollutants. Additionally, many urban centres charge extra for older diesel cars that fail to meet modern emission standards.

Ultimately, calling diesel cleaner than gasoline depends on which angle you take—global warming potential or local air quality. Diesel stands out for lowering carbon dioxide numbers, which helps with climate change targets. Yet, unless carefully managed with up-to-date technology and maintenance, diesel can pose issues for city air. Understanding how you drive and what kind of emissions rules you’re subject to can guide you toward choosing the right type of engine. There’s no perfect answer for everyone, but diesel certainly has carved out a reputation for efficiency and reduced CO2, which some consider the hallmark of being “cleaner.”

Share This Post:

Contact us

Find us on:

Newsletter